Logo Image
MLSSeattle SoundersSeason Analysis

Is Seattle the Biggest Disappointment of the 2026 MLS Season?

By Mio Ristić•
Seattle Sounders and the 2026 MLS season
Credit: Getty Images

For most of the past decade, a Seattle Sounders season ending in the Wild Card round would have been considered a failure. In 2026, it felt less like a shock than the conclusion to a decline that had been unfolding for months.

Seattle finished eighth in the Western Conference with 46 points, a 12-12-10 record and a negative goal difference. They needed a win over LAFC on Decision Day just to secure a home playoff game, then saw their season end against Real Salt Lake — a 1-1 draw followed by a 4-2 defeat on penalties.

The result was disappointing. The manner of the season was more concerning.

Seattle opened 2026 with the kind of form that suggested another serious campaign was possible. At 7-1-3, the Sounders looked organized, confident and capable of competing near the top of the West. Their early momentum made the eventual finish difficult to explain as a simple regression to the mean.

Then the season changed.

A prolonged winless stretch dragged Seattle away from the Western Conference's leading group. The team struggled to maintain consistency, failed to establish control over its matches and increasingly looked like a side trying to survive rather than dictate. By the time the playoffs arrived, the Sounders had become a team whose reputation was considerably stronger than its performances.

That is what makes 2026 such a disappointment. Seattle did not merely finish below its ambitions. It spent much of the season looking unlike the club supporters have come to expect.

A signing that raised the stakes

The arrival of Dejan Joveljić from Sporting Kansas City was supposed to give Seattle a clearer attacking identity.

The Serbian striker had already demonstrated that he could score in MLS. His move represented a significant investment in a player who could provide a reliable focal point, improve the team's finishing and help turn promising performances into victories.

Joveljić delivered individual production, but the larger problem remained unresolved.

Seattle needed more than a goalscorer. It needed a functioning attacking structure around him — a team capable of creating chances consistently, supporting runs into the box and controlling the moments after possession was lost.

Instead, Joveljić often looked like one of the few players capable of making a difference in the final third. His arrival improved the roster, but it did not repair the team's underlying problems.

That distinction matters. A successful transfer is not simply one in which a player scores goals. It is one that changes the level of the team. Seattle invested in a proven striker and still finished with a negative goal difference, eighth in the conference and facing elimination in a single game.

The signing was not necessarily a failure. The season around it was.

The problem was bigger than the attack

Seattle's difficulties were not confined to finishing.

The Sounders struggled to sustain performances over the course of a match and rarely looked like a team capable of imposing its preferred rhythm for long periods. Their early-season confidence gave way to a side that could produce moments of quality but struggled to build them into a consistent performance.

The roster still contained experienced players and established MLS talent. Brian Schmetzer remained in charge, and the club had enough quality to reach the postseason. But the gap between individual ability and collective performance became increasingly difficult to ignore.

That is the more troubling question for Seattle: why did a team with this much experience spend so much of the season looking disconnected?

The answer cannot be reduced to one injury, one transfer or one tactical decision. The season suggested a combination of problems — inconsistent availability, limited depth in key areas and an inability to find a reliable approach once the opening momentum disappeared.

The Sounders were not without talent. They were without a consistent version of themselves.

The Wild Card was a fitting ending

Seattle's playoff defeat to Real Salt Lake was not simply bad luck.

The Sounders had opportunities to take control. Albert Rusnák opened the scoring in the 36th minute, giving Seattle the advantage before halftime. But the Sounders could not turn that lead into security.

Real Salt Lake equalized through Morgan Guilavogui in the 63rd minute. The match remained level through the end of regulation, sending the teams directly to a penalty shootout.

Rafael Cabral saved penalties from Joveljić and Rusnák, while RSL converted all four of its attempts. Seattle's season ended with the same underlying frustration that had defined much of its regular season: chances created, opportunities missed and no convincing answer when the match became difficult.

The Wild Card defeat was a consequence of the season, not an isolated event.

Is Seattle the biggest disappointment in MLS?

In absolute terms, the answer is probably no.

Other clubs finished lower, missed the playoffs and endured more damaging campaigns. Sporting Kansas City, DC United and Atlanta United had their own reasons to be dissatisfied. Seattle at least reached the postseason and had a recognizable attacking threat in Joveljić.

But disappointment is not measured only by where a team finishes. It is measured by the distance between expectation and reality.

Few clubs entered 2026 with a clearer recent identity as perennial contenders. Seattle had made the playoffs in 17 of its 18 MLS seasons since joining the league in 2009 and won MLS Cup twice, in 2016 and 2019. Its history has created a standard that eighth place cannot satisfy.

The Sounders have experienced setbacks before. They missed the playoffs in 2022, a season that followed their historic Concacaf Champions Cup triumph. But that campaign felt like an exception. In 2026, the decline was more gradual and more difficult to dismiss.

The season began with genuine promise, then became a long struggle to recover it. A late victory over LAFC secured a playoff place, but it could not erase the months that came before.

What comes next?

The Sounders still have reasons to believe they can recover. The roster has talent, Schmetzer remains in place and the organization has a track record of competing at a high level.

But the next step cannot simply be another summer signing or another attempt to finish the season strongly. Seattle needs to understand why its early form disappeared and why its investment in the attack did not translate into a more complete team.

The question is not whether the Sounders can return to the playoffs. Their history suggests they can.

The question is whether they can return to being a team that expects to compete for something meaningful once it gets there.

For a club that has spent much of its MLS existence measuring success in trophies and deep playoff runs, eighth place and a Wild Card exit represent a significant underachievement.

Whether it was the biggest disappointment of the league's 2026 season remains debatable.

For Seattle, the more uncomfortable conclusion is that the season was not disappointing because it ended in penalties. It was disappointing because, by November, the Sounders had given themselves so little reason to expect anything else.